Liv-a-cide: Discovering the Healing Power of Your Story

Understanding suicide, human agency, and the possibility of creating a life worth continuing.

I have always been fascinated by the process of understanding and solving problems. When I encounter something particularly complex, I often begin by asking myself three questions: What is it? How does it work? Why does it happen?

These questions have served me well throughout my life, both personally and professionally. They allow me to approach problems from different directions, sometimes through abstract and philosophical exploration, other times through logical analysis and practical problem-solving.

As a marriage and family therapist, I have the privilege of engaging in both.

Human beings are extraordinarily complex. We are influenced by our biology, our relationships, our environments, our histories, and the meanings we assign to our experiences. We are simultaneously the authors of portions of our lives and the recipients of circumstances we never would have chosen.

And somehow, through all of this, we are expected to construct a life we can live with.

For some, that becomes an extraordinarily difficult task.

When I originally wrote about suicide in 2018, I wanted to better understand not only why people consider ending their lives, but what might help them choose to continue living. Years of clinical experience and continued reflection have only deepened my interest in that question.

What follows is a combination of professional observations, clinical principles, and my own philosophical convictions about human agency, relationships, suffering, and the remarkable capacity people have to change.

What Is Suicide, and What Are We Really Trying to End?

Suicide is the intentional ending of one’s own life.

That definition is straightforward enough. Understanding the psychological experiences that lead someone to consider suicide is considerably more complicated.

People experience suicidal thoughts for many reasons. Some struggle with psychiatric illness, trauma, grief, chronic physical pain, addiction, or profound isolation. Others find themselves confronting circumstances that seem impossible to change or experiences they cannot imagine enduring any longer.

Often, several of these conditions exist simultaneously.

But I have long been interested in a question that lies beneath these circumstances:

When someone wants to end their life, what exactly is it about that life they want to end?

I believe this question deserves far more attention than it sometimes receives.

Human beings do not develop suicidal desires in a vacuum. There is a context. There is a history. There is an experience of suffering, whether temporary or chronic, that has contributed to the person’s present understanding of their existence.

Sometimes the suffering is connected to something that happened yesterday. Sometimes it is connected to something that happened decades ago. Sometimes it involves circumstances that remain painfully present every single day.

And sometimes the most difficult part isn’t the experience itself, but the meaning that experience has come to hold in the person’s understanding of themselves and their future.

This brings me to one of the central ideas in my approach to therapy.

I believe that when people contemplate ending their lives, we should explore what has made the continuation of their story seem intolerable.

This does not mean that suicidal individuals never genuinely desire death. Some do, and that desire must be taken seriously. Nor does it mean every suicidal crisis can be explained through one psychological theory.

Rather, I am suggesting that the desire for death frequently develops in relationship to something about living that the person has come to experience as unbearable.

And if we can begin to understand what that something is, we may discover possibilities that previously seemed unavailable.

The Story We Tell Ourselves About Ourselves

Every human being has a story.

Some portions of that story are chosen. Others are written into our lives through circumstances beyond our control.

We do not choose our parents, our childhood environments, many of our losses, or the actions of people who have harmed us. We cannot simply erase experiences because they are painful, embarrassing, unjust, or inconsistent with the lives we hoped to have.

Yet we must somehow find ways to live with these realities.

Our stories are not merely collections of events. They are also the meanings we assign to those events.

Consider two people who experience similar losses. One may eventually understand the experience as a painful chapter in a continuing life. Another may experience that same kind of loss as the destruction of everything that gave life its meaning.

The event matters. The circumstances matter. But so does the interpretation.

A teenager experiencing rejection may conclude that they are fundamentally unlovable.

A person experiencing divorce may feel that the future they spent years building has disappeared, along with an important part of their identity.

Someone living with chronic illness may struggle to reconcile their present limitations with the person they once were or hoped to become.

These are not merely unpleasant thoughts that can be corrected through positive thinking. They may represent profound disruptions in how a person understands their existence.

Sometimes people find themselves living a story they cannot stomach.

And when they cannot imagine changing that story, escaping the circumstances, or discovering a different way to understand what has happened, death may begin to appear as the only remaining means of relief.

But the inability to imagine another possibility does not establish that another possibility does not exist.

That distinction is one I must punctuate.

Changing the Story Versus Changing the Circumstances

One of the things I love most about psychotherapy is that it requires both creative and practical problem-solving.

Sometimes therapy involves exploring abstract questions about identity, meaning, purpose, relationships, and the interpretation of lived experiences.

Other times, therapy involves identifying a very real problem and developing a practical plan to change it.

And quite often, effective therapy requires both.

I believe there are two broad avenues through which we can help people experiencing intolerable suffering.

1. Change the Meaning of the Story

We cannot change the historical facts of someone’s life.

An experience of abuse cannot be made to have never happened. A death cannot be undone. A betrayal cannot be erased from history.

But the meaning those experiences hold in someone’s present life is not necessarily fixed.

A person who once understood themselves exclusively as a victim may gradually discover additional dimensions of their identity.

Someone who believes their greatest failure has permanently defined them may come to recognize that failure as one part of a much larger and still developing story.

A person who has experienced devastating loss may eventually discover that continued living does not require abandoning what was lost.

These changes do not make the original experiences acceptable, nor do they require pretending that painful circumstances were somehow beneficial.

They involve learning how to assimilate difficult experiences into a broader understanding of one’s life without allowing those experiences to dictate the entirety of one’s identity or future.

I find this process remarkable.

We cannot always change what happened to us, but we may be able to change what those experiences are permitted to mean about us.

2. Change the Circumstances of the Story

There is, however, another side to this discussion.

Sometimes a person’s interpretation of their circumstances is entirely reasonable.

Sometimes their environment really is harmful. Their relationships really are destructive. Their financial circumstances really are overwhelming. Their physical pain really is debilitating.

In these situations, encouraging someone to simply reinterpret their suffering may accomplish very little.

It may even communicate that the problem exists primarily in their thinking when the problem is also very much present in their environment.

This is where practical problem-solving becomes essential.

Perhaps someone needs help leaving an abusive relationship, establishing boundaries, accessing medical care, addressing an addiction, repairing a relationship, developing financial stability, or finding a community where they experience genuine belonging.

Sometimes the most therapeutic intervention is not a profound philosophical insight.

Sometimes it is a workable plan.

And sometimes the plan must come before the insight.

The relationship between these two processes is fascinating because they continually influence one another.

Changing our interpretation of a circumstance can change our behavior. Changed behavior can influence our relationships and environments. Those changes can then provide new experiences that further alter how we understand ourselves.

Likewise, changing an oppressive or destructive environment can create the psychological space necessary to begin reconsidering beliefs that once seemed unquestionably true.

The goal is not merely to help someone think differently about an intolerable life. It is to help them discover, develop, or construct a life they can tolerate and, eventually, perhaps even enjoy.

Human Agency: The Power and Limitations of Choice

One of my deepest philosophical convictions concerns human agency.

Agency is our capacity to make choices and participate in determining the direction of our lives.

I believe this capacity is among the most consequential attributes of human existence.

We cannot choose every circumstance we encounter. We cannot control every person with whom we have a relationship. We cannot prevent every illness, loss, disappointment, or injustice.

But within the limits of our circumstances and capacities, we can often participate in deciding what happens next.

That participation matters.

However, agency should not be confused with unlimited freedom or unlimited psychological capacity.

A person experiencing severe depression, psychosis, intoxication, overwhelming trauma, or an acute suicidal crisis may have significant impairments in their ability to recognize alternatives, anticipate consequences, regulate emotions, or act consistently with their longer-term values.

Their agency has not necessarily disappeared, but their ability to exercise it may be severely constrained.

This is one reason compassion, treatment, and sometimes immediate protective intervention are so important.

I do not believe emphasizing agency requires us to ignore the conditions that restrict it.

Quite the opposite.

One of the purposes of therapy is to help people recover, strengthen, and more effectively exercise the agency available to them.

We do this by helping them recognize choices, develop skills, access resources, change environments, and understand how their experiences influence their decisions.

Agency is not simply telling someone that they have a choice.

It is helping them discover possibilities they may no longer be capable of seeing on their own.

And when someone’s immediate safety is in jeopardy, preserving their life may be necessary before meaningful exploration of those possibilities can continue.

Five Ways We Can Help Prevent Suicide

The philosophical questions surrounding suicide are important, but they should lead us toward meaningful action.

Understanding suffering is valuable. Helping alleviate it is even better.

The following are five areas I believe deserve attention when supporting people experiencing suicidal thoughts or profound emotional distress.

1. Love Them and Actually Listen

I have always believed that active listening is one of the most underestimated expressions of love.

And I am not talking about the kind of listening where someone occasionally nods while watching television or preparing their next response.

I am talking about being genuinely present.

The kind of listening where you find yourself looking into the eyes of another human being as they struggle to explain something they have never been able to put into words.

The kind where silence is not uncomfortable because neither person feels compelled to fill it.

The kind where a distressed child discovers that their feelings do not frighten you away.

People experiencing suicidal thoughts may already believe that they are a burden, that their experiences are incomprehensible to others, or that revealing their suffering will result in judgment or rejection.

Our willingness to listen can challenge those expectations.

We do not have to agree with every conclusion someone has reached about their life in order to acknowledge the legitimacy of their suffering.

And listening does not mean avoiding difficult questions.

If you are concerned that someone may be suicidal, ask them directly whether they are thinking about suicide. Asking about suicidal thoughts does not create them. It can open an important conversation and help identify when immediate support is necessary.

Sometimes love requires sitting quietly with someone.

Other times, love requires taking action to help keep them safe.

Both matter.

2. Help Them Discover Belonging

I believe belonging is among the fundamental psychological needs of human beings.

We are relational creatures.

Our identities develop through interactions with others. Our sense of worth is influenced by our experiences of acceptance and rejection. Our capacity to navigate suffering is often strengthened by knowing that we do not have to navigate it alone.

Isolation can be devastating, particularly when it reinforces a person’s belief that they are unwanted, misunderstood, or disconnected from meaningful relationships.

But belonging involves more than simply being surrounded by people.

Someone can be physically present in a crowded room and still experience profound loneliness.

Belonging develops when people experience themselves as known, accepted, and meaningfully connected.

We can help cultivate this by inviting others into our communities, maintaining relationships during difficult periods, and making room for people whose suffering may make social interaction challenging.

Sometimes the person who needs connection most is also the person who has the greatest difficulty seeking it.

Be patient with them.

And remember that belonging should not depend upon someone’s ability to be cheerful, productive, agreeable, or emotionally convenient.

People need relationships in which they are valued even when they are struggling.

3. Help Them Discover Purpose Through Responsibility and Stewardship

There is something psychologically meaningful about discovering that our existence matters to someone or something beyond ourselves.

I have long been interested in the therapeutic potential of responsibility and stewardship.

For some people, caring for a pet, nurturing a plant, participating in a community project, or contributing to the welfare of another person can create opportunities for connection, purpose, and personal competence.

A person who struggles to recognize their own worth may nevertheless experience genuine satisfaction in discovering that they can care for another living thing.

This is one reason I find animal-assisted interventions particularly interesting.

Relationships with animals can provide opportunities for attachment and affection that may feel less threatening to individuals whose experiences with human relationships have been painful.

Of course, responsibility is not universally therapeutic. Someone already overwhelmed by obligations may need relief from responsibilities rather than additional ones. A pet is not a substitute for clinical treatment, nor should someone be made to feel guilty about what would happen to others if they died.

The objective is not to burden someone with another reason they must remain alive.

It is to help them discover meaningful opportunities to participate in life.

I once heard a principle expressed through three simple needs: a friend, a responsibility, and spiritual nourishment.

I continue to find considerable wisdom in that combination.

Connection, purpose, and meaning can each contribute something important to a person’s experience of living.

4. Help Them Access Treatment and Practical Support

Some people avoid psychological treatment because they are frightened by what they might discover or remember.

Others worry about being judged, losing control, or having to revisit experiences they have spent years trying to forget.

And many encounter very practical barriers: financial limitations, transportation difficulties, scheduling conflicts, inadequate insurance coverage, or limited access to qualified professionals.

These barriers deserve attention.

Therapy should provide an environment in which people can explore difficult experiences with appropriate support, collaboration, and respect for their capacities.

The pace and intensity of treatment should be informed by the person’s needs, preferences, and clinical circumstances.

Not every painful experience must be explored immediately. Not every therapeutic intervention requires revisiting trauma in detail.

Sometimes treatment begins with stabilization, developing coping skills, improving relationships, or addressing circumstances that are actively contributing to distress.

And sometimes a person needs more immediate or intensive intervention than routine outpatient therapy can provide.

When someone is experiencing suicidal thoughts, it is important to assess the seriousness of the situation rather than assume that general encouragement or future therapy appointments will be sufficient.

This may include asking about suicidal intent, plans, access to lethal means, and the person’s ability to remain safe.

Collaborative safety planning, reducing access to potentially lethal means, involving appropriate supports, and obtaining urgent evaluation when necessary can be lifesaving.

If someone is in immediate danger, contact emergency services. 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is also available by calling or texting 988.

The broader point is that meaningful support should address both psychological and practical barriers to recovery.

Sometimes people need help understanding their story.

Sometimes they need help surviving the next several hours.

We must be prepared to recognize the difference.

5. Ask Them What Part of Their Story They Want to End

This is perhaps the most personally meaningful of the five principles I have discussed.

When someone expresses suicidal thoughts, I am interested in understanding what has become so intolerable that death has entered their consideration as a possible solution.

I want to know what they believe cannot change.

What they have lost.

What they fear they will never recover.

What they believe their experiences say about who they are.

What kind of future they anticipate, and why that future has become unbearable.

In addition to directly assessing suicidal thoughts and safety, one question I have found philosophically and therapeutically valuable is:

“What part of your story do you wish you could get rid of?”

The question is not intended to minimize someone’s desire for death or assume that I already understand their motivation.

It is an invitation to explore the relationship between their suffering and their desire to escape it.

Sometimes the answer involves a circumstance that can be changed.

Sometimes it involves a loss that cannot be reversed.

Sometimes it involves shame, guilt, fear, loneliness, or a belief about themselves that has become inseparable from their identity.

And sometimes the person does not yet know the answer.

That is okay.

We can begin with what they do know.

I am particularly interested in helping people recognize that their story is not necessarily finished simply because they cannot presently imagine a tolerable continuation.

An individual may have experienced significant and irreversible loss without being irrecoverably lost themselves.

They may be unable to change an important chapter of their life while still retaining opportunities to influence chapters that have not yet been written.

This is not a promise that everything will work out exactly as they hope.

It is an acknowledgment that the future contains possibilities that cannot always be perceived from within the suffering of the present.

And discovering those possibilities is among the most meaningful aspects of my work as a therapist.

Spirituality, Meaning, and the Parts of Ourselves We Cannot Easily Measure

I would be neglecting an important part of my own philosophy if I failed to address spirituality.

I recognize that spirituality means different things to different people.

For some, it is inseparable from religious faith and a relationship with God.

For others, it involves personal values, ethical commitments, a sense of connection to humanity, or the search for meaning and purpose.

I do not believe a person must share my religious convictions to experience meaningful psychological growth.

But I do believe that questions about meaning, identity, responsibility, and purpose deserve serious consideration in psychotherapy.

We are not merely collections of symptoms to be managed.

We are people attempting to understand ourselves and our place in the world.

For many individuals, spiritual or philosophical reflection provides a framework through which suffering can be understood without becoming the entirety of their identity.

For others, meaning develops through relationships, creativity, service, learning, or commitment to personally significant values.

The specific source of meaning may differ, but the therapeutic question remains relevant:

What makes continued living meaningful to this particular person?

I do not presume to answer that question for my clients.

I consider it a privilege to help them explore their own answers.

Where There Is Life, There Is Hope

I recognize that hope can be a difficult subject for someone experiencing profound despair.

Telling someone to have hope does not necessarily make hope accessible.

Sometimes the very experiences that bring someone into therapy have undermined their confidence that anything can improve.

And sometimes their skepticism is understandable.

They may have tried repeatedly to change their circumstances without success. They may have experienced multiple losses, disappointing treatments, or relationships that promised safety and delivered harm.

I do not believe we should respond to these experiences with empty reassurance.

Hope does not require pretending that suffering is insignificant.

Nor does it require certainty that the future will unfold according to our preferences.

Sometimes hope begins with something much smaller.

The recognition that a circumstance may be changeable.

The discovery that an experience may hold a different meaning than previously understood.

The possibility that a relationship can be repaired, a boundary established, a skill developed, or a new direction pursued.

Sometimes hope begins when another person can imagine possibilities that we cannot yet imagine for ourselves.

And sometimes, during an acute crisis, hope begins with the decision to remain safe long enough to explore those possibilities with support.

I believe there is tremendous significance in helping people discover that they are more than the worst things that have happened to them.

More than their failures.

More than their diagnoses.

More than their losses.

More than the painful conclusions they have reached about themselves.

Their experiences are real, and some of those experiences may never be undone.

But their story is larger than any single chapter.

Liv-a-cide: Choosing to Continue the Story

Several years ago, I wrote a song called Liv-a-cide.

The title is a deliberate play on the word suicide.

Where suicide describes the ending of one’s life, I wanted Liv-a-cide to represent the courageous decision to continue living, particularly when doing so feels extraordinarily difficult.

The song emerged from years of witnessing the suffering associated with suicide and reflecting upon the strength sometimes required simply to remain alive.

It is not intended to suggest that suicidal suffering can be overcome through willpower alone.

Rather, it expresses my admiration for people who, often with considerable support and treatment, continue choosing life despite circumstances that make doing so painful.

There is something remarkable about that decision.

Not because continuing to live guarantees an easy future.

Not because every painful experience will eventually make sense.

And certainly not because people who struggle to remain alive are somehow deficient in courage or character.

But because continued life preserves the possibility of change.

The possibility of new relationships.

The possibility of healing.

The possibility of circumstances that do not yet exist.

And perhaps most importantly, the possibility of discovering that experiences once believed to define the entirety of one’s existence were, in fact, only portions of a much larger story.

This is one of the reasons I love being a therapist.

I get to participate in the extraordinary process of helping people understand their experiences, examine their assumptions, change their circumstances, and discover possibilities they may have stopped believing were available.

Sometimes that work is deeply philosophical.

Sometimes it is remarkably practical.

Most often, it is both.

And I cannot think of many things more meaningful than helping another human being discover that their story is still worth continuing.

Where there is life, there remains the possibility of writing another chapter.

— Adam Bertoch, MS, LMFT, LCDC

A note about safety: This article is intended for education and reflection, not as a substitute for individualized suicide risk assessment or treatment. If you or someone you know is experiencing suicidal thoughts, professional and crisis support is available. Call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. If there is immediate danger, call 911 or seek emergency medical care.

Original music: Liv-a-cide

Listen to Liv-a-cide